This article originally appeared on Too Much Coffee Copyright 2004 and is reproduced with permission. The photos are by INeedCoffee and are available for unrestricted use with attribution under the Creative Commons license.
This article is meant to be used as a basic introduction. There are no right or wrong ways of cupping, but this should help for the novice who wishes to enjoy the delights of origin coffee.
The aim is to introduce you to what cupping is, why we cup, how we cup and some of the more commonly used terms and evaluation methods.
People in the trade will have you believe that coffee cupping is a science, an exact art requiring a lot of expertise. To some extent this can be true, but this should not put off the enthusiast from enjoying it too. It can be very simple (and enjoyable) and there are no right or wrong answers. Your palate may pick up hints of a taste that the most season cupper would not, as each person can find different things in the cup.
What is cupping?
Cupping is a method of evaluating different characteristics of a particular coffee bean. Cupping allows us to compare and contrast coffees against each other, and allows us to get a better understanding of each coffee.
Its important that you so use the same method each time as this can have an effect on the results, so if cupping is being used as a comparison / evaluation tool then uniformity is key.
We cup coffees to understand their basic tastes. This can help us understand where different coffees could be slotted into blends not only for this brewing method but all other methods too. It also makes us look at coffee in its basic form and appreciate some of its finer points. As already said it’s a fantastic evaluation tool for something that changes from farm to farm, region to region, country to country and crop to crop.
How to cup?
There are no right or wrong ways of cupping coffee. What I will tell you here is the textbook way of doing it. What I will suggest is any method you use that you always use that method. Any deviations will mean you lose many of the tools you can use to compare like with like.
I prefer to roast all my samples to a light roast. This allows the delicacies or the faults to stand out and not get complicated by roast type tastes. Once again this is a personal choice, not a rule.
For a more professional atmosphere it is a nice idea to have a sample of the green raw coffee, the roasted coffee and some ground coffee. Although this is not essential it allows you to judge the quality of the grade, smell the dry grounds and see the quality of the greens.
Coffee Tasting Table
The method I will use here uses the infusion type of brewing. Grind up your rested coffee (two days rest is a minimum in my opinion) to a coarse jug type grind. Place the grounds in a small bowl. Pour over nearly boiling water (195-205 °F, 95 °C). Allow the grinds to infuse for around 3-4 minutes.
A point quite often missed by some cupping sessions I have been to is that breaking the crust of the bowl will give you a great deal of insight into what is about to come. Take time to smell the coffee at this stage as it will give hints of the kind of things to be looking out for, come the tasting.
Once the crust has been broken start to stir the bowl gently allowing some of the grinds to sink to the bottom. Any left on top of the bowl should be scooped away with spoons.
Once the surface of the coffee infusion is clear of grinds the slurping may commence. Don’t be afraid to sound a little silly whilst doing this: everyone does. When at cupping events I try to make the silliest noise I can, without getting spotted by others for making it. It’s a great game and all should play along with it. Take a deep spoon (a soup spoon is a good substitute for the traditional cupping spoon) and fill it with your infusion. Bring the spoon up to your mouth, and inhale (well suck powerfully anyway!), drawing the coffee to the roof of the mouth to tickle the tongue and then fall into the back of the mouth. This creates a coffee vapour to stimulate that part of your sense of taste which is actually your sense of smell. Then roll the coffee around the mouth and begin to look for tastes that you can compare it to.
It’s really easy once you’re here, and don’t be afraid to say what you can taste. I’ve found things in coffee others haven’t and I’ve also found things that everyone noticed. There are no wrongs or rights, just opinions. Now this again is choice but I prefer to spit out the coffee. It seems a waste but after 12-18 coffees even a die-hard caffeine addict like myself can start to feel a little funny from the effects. Also it’s hard work on the taste buds if you’re swallowing it all, and you’re being unfair on the later coffees. Anyway coffee should be drunk not slurped!
It’s always a good idea to keep notes whilst doing all this. One of the best cupping forms I have used is the one created by Phil Jordan of www.toomuchcoffee.com and can be found in the Downloads section of that web site.
So what are you looking for?
Fragrance of dry grounds
Does it smell fresh? Does it smell stale? Over roasted? Under roasted? This is a great place to find out.
Fragrance of wet grounds
Aroma: what’s there? The water mixing with the coffee and oxygen will produce a more intense smell than with the dry grounds.
Acidity / Liveliness
Acidity in coffee can be a welcome attribute, or it can be a most unwelcome one. In one form it can give liveliness and freshness to the flavour. In another form it can appear as sourness. Coffee without acidity is lifeless. Coffee with too much or the wrong sort of acidity can be unpleasant, even sour. If the acidity is unpleasant, pleasant, fresh, sour, or whatever – make a note.
Body is a description of the fullness and richness of the feel of the coffee in your mouth.
Flavour / Depth
What’s there? This is the fun part. Is there chocolate? Fruit?
- Spicy (and what kind of spice?)
What does the coffee leave in your mouth when you have finished? Aftertaste is a very important part of the cup.
How would you summarise the coffee? Is there anything you want to say about it that you haven’t been able to express in any of the specific sections of the cupping form?
In conclusion I hope that this guide is helpful. I am by no means an expert on cupping but I am a great believer in its utility in the evaluation of fine coffees.
This is just a set of guidelines and there are no hard and fast rules Everyone from the beginner to the expert can gain a great deal from the experience of cupping.